This yr marks 30 years for the reason that launch of Mariah Carey’s hit, “All I Need for Christmas is You.” However have another pop singles been capable of enter the vacation music canon since?
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
The vacations are upon us, which suggests this one tune would possibly really feel nearly inescapable.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU”)
MARIAH CAREY: (Singing) I do not need so much for Christmas. There is only one factor I would like.
SUMMERS: That, after all, is Mariah Carey’s “All I Need For Christmas Is You.” It first got here out – are you able to consider this? – 30 years in the past, although its ubiquity this time of yr sort of makes it seem to be it has been round endlessly.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU”)
CAREY: (Singing) I do not need so much for Christmas. There is only one factor I would like. And I do not care in regards to the presents…
SUMMERS: Whether or not you play it on a loop or whether or not it drives you loopy, there isn’t any query Mariah Carey’s tune has develop into a everlasting fixture of the Christmas tune canon. That vacation tune canon is massive, however it isn’t simple to interrupt into. You possibly can take your choose of pop artists who’ve made their very own yuletide jingle since 1994, like John Legend…
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “BRING ME LOVE”)
JOHN LEGEND: (Singing) Child, I hope Santa brings you to me.
SUMMERS: …Justin Bieber…
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “MISTLETOE”)
JUSTIN BIEBER: (Singing) I ought to be taking part in within the winter snow, however I’ma (ph) be below the mistletoe.
SUMMERS: …Taylor Swift.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “CHRISTMAS MUST BE SOMETHING”)
TAYLOR SWIFT: (Singing) Christmas should be one thing extra.
SUMMERS: However not even the lady who shattered data along with her Eras tour has given us a vacation tune that has had the endurance worthy of the canon. Was Mariah Carey’s tune the final? Who else has made a tune worthy of consideration? To debate, we have got NPR Music’s Stephen Thompson right here within the studio. He is been dancing together with the music. Hey, Stephen.
STEPHEN THOMPSON, BYLINE: Hi there, Juana.
SUMMERS: Stephen, I do know numerous ink has been spilled about “All I Need For Christmas Is You,” however for the choose few individuals on the market who usually are not Carey converts and even for individuals who like to take heed to the tune each season with out enthusiastic about it, what’s it in regards to the tune? Why do you assume it really works so nicely?
THOMPSON: Properly, I feel it manages to mix numerous what works in one of the best Christmas music, which is a way of timelessness, a nostalgic by way of line again to issues like lady teams. Like, if you concentrate on “A Christmas Present For You” from Phil Spector, with these nice Ronettes songs on it…
SUMMERS: Proper.
THOMPSON: …It is tapping into a few of that stuff. It is also simply an impeccably produced tune. The way in which the (vocalizing) is available in is difficult to withstand, although I do know there are lots of individuals listening to this for whom familiarity has managed to construct up an unlimited wellspring of contempt. It’s a tune that’s wildly, wildly overplayed.
SUMMERS: I imply, to begin with, I’ll simply notice that the tune goes to be caught in my head for the remainder of the day, so…
THOMPSON: I am so sorry.
SUMMERS: Thanks for that. However query right here – I am curious. What do you assume it’s? What are the substances that one must create a genuinely good and lasting Christmas tune?
THOMPSON: For me, one of many first issues that I search for is sincerity. I’ll typically be drawn to vacation music that has actual feeling to it. I am typically drawn to some notice of melancholy. Despite the fact that there’s not quite a lot of melancholy in “All I Need For Christmas Is You”…
SUMMERS: Proper.
THOMPSON: …Lots of the Christmas music that I am drawn to has this sense that the vacations usually are not 100% cheerful. And after I take into consideration the Christmas music or the vacation music that I hate, it is music that’s primarily asking, why aren’t you cheerful? And that’s simply the cruelest factor you may do for – to me, you recognize? And I’d a lot fairly you make me unhappy than inform me I ought to be pleased.
SUMMERS: Are there any Christmas songs which are written after the discharge of Mariah Carey’s hit that you simply assume do deserve a spot within the canon? I wish to hear about your vacation playlist.
THOMPSON: Yeah. I imply, I am always railing about this as a result of there was a ton of magnificent vacation music made within the final 30 years. We have in some way determined as a society that we’re solely going to take heed to about eight Christmas songs.
SUMMERS: Yep.
THOMPSON: And certainly one of them is “Jingle Bell Rock,” and certainly one of them is by Andy Williams.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “IT’S THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME OF THE YEAR”)
ANDY WILLIAMS: (Singing) It is probably the most great time of the yr.
THOMPSON: There’s a Christmas canon that sprawls out for 1000’s and 1000’s of songs. And a few of them are magnificent and ought to be simply as well-liked as “All I Need For Christmas Is You,” which is a tune I do like.
SUMMERS: OK – like what, although? Give me some examples.
THOMPSON: OK. I will offer you an instance. It is a tune from 2003 by a duo known as The Weepies. And I do know. The Weepies – you are going to be like, OK, unhappy Christmas. Here is unhappy boy, speaking about his unhappy Christmas music. I perceive. I do know what you are considering, individuals. They’ve a tune known as “All That I Need,” which, to me, is likely one of the most irresistibly stunning Christmas songs I’ve ever heard.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “ALL THAT I WANT”)
THE WEEPIES: (Singing) …With all that I need, all that I need.
THOMPSON: It is a tune that has numerous sort of traditional vacation tune signifiers. Nevertheless it’s a tune about discovering consolation within the love in your life, in your loved ones, in sort of a few of the majesty and fantastic thing about winter with out it ringing false in any approach. And I acquired to say, Deb Talan’s voice is rather like a balm on my soul.
SUMMERS: Completely.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “ALL THAT I WANT”)
THE WEEPIES: (Singing) The ships are available. It is Christmas time.
SUMMERS: Give us one other instance of a tune that’s in your vacation playlist.
THOMPSON: Properly, one other one in a bit bit the identical vein of simply deep, deep heat – there is a band known as Low. Low, you recognize, was round for, like, 30 years, put out a ton of actually gorgeous data. And in 1999 they put out an album known as “Christmas.” And for me, after I take into consideration songs that ought to be within the vacation canon, I take into consideration the tune “Simply Like Christmas” by Low.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “JUST LIKE CHRISTMAS”)
LOW: (Singing) The beds had been small, however we felt so younger. It was identical to Christmas.
THOMPSON: There’s one thing in regards to the manufacturing of this tune the place it feels prefer it’s being beamed in from, like, a faraway satellite tv for pc otherwise you’re listening to it on an AM radio. And a lot Christmas music has these emotions of nostalgia that may really feel actually compelled. And for me, this tune has fully unforced nostalgia.
SUMMERS: Stephen, past these two examples, are there another songs that you may see getting extra well-liked with age?
THOMPSON: I consider any person like a Kelly Clarkson – you recognize, a pop singer with a extremely, actually massive and vibrant voice. And she or he’s leaned into the vacations in ways in which I feel are sort of scratching the itch that Mariah Carey is scratching a bit bit.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “UNDERNEATH THE TREE”)
KELLY CLARKSON: (Singing) You are right here, the place you ought to be. Snow is falling because the carolers sing. It simply wasn’t the identical alone on Christmas day.
THOMPSON: She’s drawing on lady teams and traditional pop and requirements in ways in which nonetheless really feel up to date.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “A NONSENSE CHRISTMAS”)
SABRINA CARPENTER: (Singing) Suppose I solely need you below my mistletoe.
THOMPSON: I feel Sabrina Carpenter, you recognize, who’s had this huge 2024 – you take a look at on the Christmas canon she’s began to place collectively. She has a Christmas particular on Netflix.
SUMMERS: Proper.
THOMPSON: She’s acquired an actual humorousness.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “A NONSENSE CHRISTMAS”)
CARPENTER: (Singing) Let me come heat you up. You been out within the snow. Child, my tongue goes numb – feels like ho, ho, ho. I do not need Santa’s elves…
THOMPSON: I feel she’s any person who actually might sort of proceed to develop into being one of many queens of Christmas. And also you simply by no means know when a type of songs goes to interrupt by way of and out of the blue it is on all of these Christmas playlists. However I actually encourage individuals listening at house to trace down your personal favourite vacation music. Go on Spotify. Go on YouTube. Get down a rabbit gap of some stunning Christmas music that evokes extra than simply this canned cheer.
SUMMERS: NPR Music’s Stephen Thompson. Stephen, thanks as at all times.
THOMPSON: Thanks, Juana.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “A NONSENSE CHRISTMAS”)
CARPENTER: (Singing) I am speaking decking all of the halls. I am speaking spiking eggnog. I am speaking reverse of small. I am speaking massive snowballs. You bought a brand new toy for me. I am out right here trimming the tree. I caught that vacation glee…
Copyright © 2024 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content is probably not in its remaining type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability might fluctuate. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.
