Billy Joel in 1977.
Artwork Maillet/Sony Music Archives/HBO
conceal caption
toggle caption
Artwork Maillet/Sony Music Archives/HBO
Fandom, like stardom, invitations mythmaking. So I can not make certain I am proper after I say my appreciation of Billy Joel took off someplace round 1983, at a home the place I used to be babysitting. That they had a VHS copy of Billy Joel: Dwell From Lengthy Island, a dwell efficiency recorded in December 1982. I did not know that the rationale his left thumb was bandaged, and the rationale he stored shaking his hand prefer it was hurting, was the horrible motorbike accident he’d had earlier that 12 months that cemented the top of his marriage and his working relationship along with his first spouse and supervisor, Elizabeth Weber.
The private and the inventive hardly ever lower aside cleanly.
I did not actually care in regards to the private; it was the piano taking part in that labored on me. After I was rising up, my mother performed ragtime in our home, so I had a tender spot for pianists. (We will not converse of the boy upon whose piano I used to lean within the method of Lucy and Schroeder.) I solely ever noticed Joel dwell as soon as, on the Spectrum in Philadelphia when he was touring for The Bridge in 1986 and 1987. However this was my favourite music in highschool, and in school, and past. I knew each phrase — really, each phrase. I knew the story about how his first album, Chilly Spring Harbor, was ruined in manufacturing. I discovered a simplified model of “Summer time, Highland Falls” on our lounge piano. I owned, on cassette, the 1970 album launched by his hair band, Attila.
The brand new two-part HBO documentary Billy Joel: And So It Goes, directed and produced by Susan Lacy and Jessica Levin, will get consideration for what it has to say about his private life. Not as a result of it is an exposé; quite the opposite, the undertaking had his cooperation, with all of the questions that association raises. As Eric Deggans wrote, there’s a variety of confession (from him) and forgiveness (from others) in these 5 hours or so, and that may be touching whereas additionally scary some skepticism. It isn’t all people who can have all 4 of his wives seem in a documentary like this and appear to be at one thing like peace with those he is not married to anymore, not less than sufficient for them to take part.
That looks like a credit score to them, given the tales they inform about instances when he was not nice to be married to. “An excessive amount of ingesting, for a very long time” is a theme that comes up time and again within the tales of each Weber and Joel’s second spouse, Christie Brinkley.
Realizing a variety of the anecdotes, realizing I did not must be satisfied of his affect, and realizing I used to be not invested in his marriages and motorbike accidents, I wasn’t positive I wanted this undertaking. However I did, because it seems. To study his inventive course of now that I am older and have finished extra creating of my very own, to rethink what I knew and did not know of his biography, to replicate on his cultural positioning with extra distance, and particularly to excavate what it was about these specific information that caught to me so stubbornly.
A music biography about music
If the documentary has a thesis, it is that Billy Joel constructed a profession on an particularly potent mixture of three strengths: songwriting (particularly melodies), piano taking part in and dwell efficiency. That final one is usually neglected, but it surely’s vital; I do not assume it is a coincidence that I grew to become a fan after I watched a video of him performing dwell. Within the ’70s, ’80s and early ’90s, when he was releasing studio albums, he was energetic and loose-limbed on stage — leaping and working, dancing, joking round with the band. He was high-energy and theatrical, charismatic, playful and humorous, despite the fact that within the final couple of a long time, his picture has been of a person seated at a piano at Madison Sq. Backyard.
Billy Joel in 1981.
Dan Weeks/Billy Joel Archives/HBO
conceal caption
toggle caption
Dan Weeks/Billy Joel Archives/HBO
None of it will have been something with out songwriting. And So It Goes attracts strains for individuals who know this music effectively, forwards and backwards between what you heard and the place it got here from. Generally that is about lyrics: He considerably reluctantly owns the truth that “Stiletto,” from 52nd Avenue, written late in his first marriage, is “sort of a nasty music” about that relationship. (Weber dryly refers to it as “one among my favourite songs of all time.”) Generally it is about complete albums: He says he needed to write down Glass Homes, a extra rambunctious report than his others as much as that time, partly as a result of he was beginning to play massive arenas and needed music for these settings. Generally it is about manufacturing and personnel: He modified bands late in his profession after having the identical guys with him for a few years, on the urging of a brand new producer. (The previous band members, just like the ex-wives, do not current as bitter. That does not imply they weren’t damage.)
Connections are plentiful between his life and his songs, and as he says, he does not actually function in simile and metaphor that a lot — he writes like he talks. And he typically writes songs about, or not less than songs impressed by, issues which can be taking place. Why was he writing a lot in regards to the West and about California within the early Seventies? As a result of he and Weber had moved on the market. Why did he sound a lot like he kinda hated it? As a result of he kinda hated it. Why does he typically come off in his personal lyrics like a petulant jerk? As a result of typically he was being a petulant jerk. Why did he write such attractive love songs whereas he was married to Weber? As a result of he was deeply in love together with her, and he liked to write down about her and write to her, and he dumped all the things into songs at the moment: anger, love, resentment (a lot of that), reduction. And why was there typically such a measure of self-loathing within the phrases he sang? Properly.
Meet the (first) spouse
Elizabeth Weber is, if not the hero, not less than the co-protagonist of the primary of the 2 installments of the documentary. The break between the movie’s two components occurs at their divorce, which divides his profession into the Elizabeth period and the post-Elizabeth period. It could be simple — it was simple — for folks to attract her as a killjoy or as controlling, as a result of she was his supervisor whereas they have been married, and since everybody agrees she was the designated grownup when the band was touring (and ingesting). She was dealing principally with males within the music enterprise, and few of them took her significantly, each as a result of she was a girl and since she was the artist’s spouse. She did not get to be in a star supercouple in the identical method Brinkley did; she did not get to be a canopy lady. She labored on his profession, actually laborious, when he wasn’t actually well-known but, and she or he caught a variety of static for it.
However the documentary makes clear that there’s little or no likelihood Joel would have had the profession he did with out her. She dealt with enterprise when he would not, and she or he had instincts about music, too, typically instincts that counterbalanced his: These interviewed are in settlement that no person was positive “Simply The Method You Are,” which supercharged Joel’s profession within the late Seventies, ought to be a single off The Stranger or ought to even seem on the album besides for her. (And Linda Ronstadt, when she heard it. And Phoebe Snow. Discover a sample?) So no matter management Joel had over the manufacturing of the documentary, it does not forestall the primary half from functioning partially as a correction of the report in favor of his first spouse, to whom he hasn’t been married in additional than 40 years.
In line with Elizabeth Weber, by the way in which, after they broke up professionally and personally within the early ’80s, Joel insisted on hiring her brother Frank as his subsequent supervisor, which she suggested in opposition to. Years later, Joel sued Frank Weber for $90 million, claiming he misappropriated massive quantities of cash.
The issue of cool
Tales about pop musicians typically run into internecine battles over what’s cool and what’s not. After I was younger, I did not care whether or not liking Billy Joel was cool — most of what I preferred (musicals, Harlequin romances, writing) wasn’t cool. However I feel I at all times knew he cared deeply and could not assist it. Rock critics principally hated him: As critic Steven Hyden explains in And So It Goes, despite the fact that all people knew he might write a melody, he was nothing just like the anti-establishment punk music they have been championing on the time he obtained well-known, and a variety of them took his place as a top-seller with Columbia Information as ample proof that he was the despised institution, the enemy.
However to him, he was a child who grew up poor with a single mother, the uncommon divorced household in his neighborhood, the uncommon Jewish household in his neighborhood. He obtained badly burned by his first report contract, he liked rock and roll, and he was by no means comfy or accepted within the California scene the place some folks thought he belonged within the ’70s, with guys like James Taylor and Jackson Browne. (Within the documentary, musician and producer Danny Kortchmar notes that it was laborious for Joel and his music to slot in on the market, possibly as a result of he was “too New York,” a loaded phrase if ever there was one.) He made the sorts of music he actually preferred, writing about all of the issues he was concerned with.
In Joel’s thoughts, what did he ever do to need to be handled like he was tender? Or phony?
Billy Joel in 1962.
Billy Joel Archives/HBO
conceal caption
toggle caption
Billy Joel Archives/HBO
And the extra it bothered him that critics hated him, the extra they hated him, as a result of nothing is much less cool than being bothered that individuals do not assume you are cool and truly complaining about it. If you happen to weren’t a greedy try-hard earlier than, buddy, effectively, you’re one now.
It obtained nasty: He would rip up critiques on stage, and on reflection, a few of these critiques appear overheated and somewhat disingenuous themselves. (On display screen, we see a pan of the retro-flavored An Harmless Man report that questioned how this man dared to assume he had the suitable to mimic the good Frankie Valli — and misspelled it as “Frankie Vallie.”) There was a gaudiness to a number of the thumbs-down takes, as if there have been factors to be earned by making them as devastating as potential. Artists usually are not the one ones who might stand to recover from themselves every now and then, in any case, and critics usually are not immune from obsessing over their very own standing.
Bruce Springsteen and Paul McCartney discuss kindly about Joel and his music in And So It Goes, each helpfully recognized of their chyrons as “MUSICIAN.” So do Pink, Sting, Nas, Garth Brooks and Itzhak Perlman. I wish to imagine that no a part of Joel nonetheless appears to be like at that and thinks, “See? They assume I am cool.”
Distress loves … music
One thing that Hyden says late within the documentary struck me as notably smart and doubtless related to my teenage self: that Billy Joel writes about “existential dissatisfaction.” He writes songs about why nothing is going on, or why all the things feels empty, or why one thing fell aside. Hyden additionally factors out that a variety of these songs work not less than as effectively coming from a man who’s 70 as they did from a man who was 30. Perhaps that is why Joel’s profession and his music have lasted so lengthy, and why he was successful at Madison Sq. Backyard for a decade, up till the summer time of final 12 months. Being unfulfilled, as a subject, does not age as surprisingly as some pop themes would possibly. Restlessness endures, as does love.
Billy Joel (heart) with Doug Stegmeyer, Jeff Schock, Rick London and Tim McCarthy in 1979.
Billy Joel Archives/HBO
conceal caption
toggle caption
Billy Joel Archives/HBO
That restlessness additionally reveals up in Joel’s tendency to complain, which he acknowledges. It has blown up in his face loads — with critics, sure, however Weber additionally says that writing “The Entertainer,” which was an inventory of grievances in opposition to his report firm, served solely to alienate individuals who have been making an attempt to assist him. It is a sort of ouroboros of self-sabotage, the place the shortcoming to ever be happy pushes satisfaction farther and farther away.
Perhaps it is this sense of looking out and by no means fairly discovering, of constructing errors that damage your self as a lot as anyone, that made this good teenager music for me. Perhaps I ought to have been centered on insurrection, however I used to be too moody to muster the vitality.
Joel does not write songs anymore. He says he simply ran out of issues he needed to say and obtained bored with the construction of pop music. He is married once more, he has children along with his present spouse, and he says he is making an attempt to be the sort of dad he did not get to have. Issues aren’t simple: He shared in Could that he’d been recognized with regular strain hydrocephalus, a mind situation docs instructed NPR is treatable, however typically ignored. He is not performing, not less than for the second, whereas that is being managed.
However the very first thing I did after I completed watching the documentary was to return to the albums and begin originally. The phrases are principally nonetheless in there someplace, caught within the again corners of the underside drawers of my reminiscence, in that method the place you could not write them down on a clean sheet of paper, but when the music begins taking part in, they appear to materialize in your mouth, line by line, proper earlier than it is time to sing them out loud within the automotive. I’m buzzing these songs in my kitchen. I’m wishing I had seen him dwell a number of extra instances. I’m wishing I had gotten higher on the piano.
